Monday, November 29, 2021

The reason why Kanoya Heart Center measures blood pressure before vaccinating against COVID-19 is because we believe that it is better for safe vaccination.

At the Kanoya Heart Center, we have been measuring blood pressure before vaccination with the COVID-19 vaccine. The person in the figure below is in his 60s, but he had never had a checkup and was not taking any medication. His blood pressure before inoculation was 254 mmHg. I was surprised. It is no wonder that such a person could die of intracerebral hemorrhage at any time. We decided not to vaccinate him, but to wait until his high blood pressure was under control. His blood pressure is now normal, and he was able to complete the vaccination successfully.

Is such a person an exception? The figure above is from the guidelines published by the Japan Society of Hypertension. It is an estimate, but there are 18.5 million people with untreated hypertension in Japan. If the population of people over 12 years old who are eligible for vaccination is 110 million, 17% of them have hypertension. That's about 1 in 6 people. The number of people with extreme cases like the one in the figure below is probably much smaller, but I think it is important to remember that a not small number of people at risk of sudden death are coming for vaccinations.


As of November 2021, about 1,300 people have died after vaccination in Japan. Of these, 389 were deaths of cardiac origin closely related to hypertension, 180 were deaths of the cerebral nervous system such as cerebral hemorrhage and infarction, and 61 were aortic dissection. In total, 620 people died. Approximately half of the deaths were related to hypertension.

Considering this, I thought it would be safer to measure blood pressure before vaccination and suspend vaccination in high-risk patients, and to treat hypertension first and then vaccinate. I thought it would be safer to treat the hypertension first and then vaccinate after it had stabilized. Of the approximately 1,200 people who first came to our clinic for vaccination, about 100 had high blood pressure at the time of the first vaccination, and we asked them to measure their blood pressure at home until the second vaccination three weeks later. As a result, half of the patients, about 50, also had high blood pressure at home, so we started their treatment.

Before the corona vaccination started, there was a discussion in the Kanoya Medical Association. There was a debate in the Kanoya Medical Association before the COVID-19 vaccination started, between medical institutions that would measure blood pressure and those that would not. One of the doctors at the medical institution that said they would not do it said that he asked an infectious disease specialist and was told that it was unnecessary, so he would not do it. I am sure that the infectious disease specialists do not know that there are so many people with untreated hypertension. Therefore, I believe that cardiologists are the ones who should be consulted to ensure the safe implementation of vaccination.

The third round of vaccinations will begin soon. For safer vaccination, I recommend that blood pressure be measured at each medical institution where vaccinations are given. If possible, mass vaccination is also recommended, but it may be difficult. If this is the case, we recommend that the person receiving the vaccination bring a record of their home blood pressure to the vaccination site for their own protection.

Sunday, November 28, 2021

鹿屋ハートセンターが新型コロナワクチン接種前に血圧測定をするわけ。3回目の接種でも安全な接種のため血圧のチェックはした方が良いと考えています。

 

 鹿屋ハートセンターでは、新型コロナワクチン接種に際して、接種前の血圧測定を実施してきました。下の図の方は、60歳代の方ですが、検診を一度も受けたことがなく何も内服していなかった方です。接種前の血圧が254mmHgです。驚きました。こんな方はいつ脳内出血を起こして亡くなられても不思議ではありません。ワクチン接種は見合わせ、高血圧のコントロールがついてからの接種としました。今では血圧も正常となり、ワクチン接種も無事に終えることができました。

このような方は例外でしょうか?上の図は、高血圧学会が公開しているガイドライン中の図です。推計ですが、全国に未治療の高血圧の人が1850万人です。ワクチン接種対象の12歳以上人口が1億1000万人として17%が高血圧の人です。およそ6人に1人です。下の図のような極端な人はもっと少ないでしょうが、突然死のリスクを抱えた人が少なからずワクチン接種に来ていることを忘れてはいけないと思っています。

2021年11月の時点で、ワクチン接種後に亡くなられた方は約1300人です。そのうち、高血圧と関連が深い心臓由来の死亡が389名、脳出血や脳梗塞などの脳神経系の死亡が180名、大動脈解離が61名です。計620人です。およそ亡くなられた方の半数は高血圧と関連した死亡です。

こんな風に考えるとワクチン接種前に血圧測定をしてハイリスクな方ではワクチン接種を見合わせ、高血圧の治療を先行し安定後にワクチン接種をした方が安全だろうと私は考えたのです。未治療の高血圧があることを見つけ、そこに介入することでワクチン接種後の死亡を減らせるのではないかと考えたのです。当院にワクチン接種のために初めて訪れられた約1200名の方のうち100名ほどが初回接種で高血圧であり、3週間後の2回目接種まで、家庭での血圧測定をお願いしました。結果、半数の50名ほどの方は家庭血圧も高値であったために治療を開始しました。

コロナワクチン接種が始まる前に鹿屋医師会の中でも議論がありました。血圧測定をするという医療機関としないという医療機関の間での議論です。しないという医療機関の先生のお一人は感染症の専門医に質問したら不要だと言われたのでしないというお話でした。感染症の専門医の先生はこれほど多くの未治療の高血圧の方がおられることをきっと知らないと思います。なので、ワクチン接種の安全な実施のために意見を聞くべきは循環器医なのだと思っています。

3回目のワクチン接種が間もなく始まります。より安全なワクチン接種のために医療機関で行われる接種では各医療機関で血圧測定をされることをお勧めします。できれば、集団接種もですが、難しいかもしれません。ならば、接種を受けられる方が自身を守るために家庭血圧の記録を接種会場に持参されるようにお勧めします。